Can A Will Be Challenged After Death?

Many people assume that once a will is registered it cannot be contested. This brings us to the question: Can a registered will be challenged after death? Yes, a will can be challenged after the death of the testator (the person who made the will) in India. 

Can You Challenge a Will after Death?

Here are some common grounds for challenging a will:

• If it is proven that the testator lacked the mental capacity to make the will at the time it was executed, then the will can be challenged.

• A will can be contested if it is shown that someone manipulated or pressured the testator into making the will in their favour.

• If there is evidence that the will was forged or created through fraudulent means, it can be challenged. 

• A will must comply with the legal formalities laid down in the Indian Succession Act, 1925. If these formalities are not followed, the will can be challenged.

• While a testator has the right to dispose of their property as they wish, disinheriting legal heirs such as children or spouses without reasonable explanation can challenge the will.

• If the language of the will is ambiguous or contains contradictions, beneficiaries may challenge the will to clarify its meaning.

To challenge a will, an interested party, usually a legal heir, must file a civil suit in the appropriate court.

Read More:

Recently one of my clients asked, can a registered will be challenged after death? I informed him that yes, a will can be challenged after the death of the person who made it (the testator). Contesting a will is a legal process where the validity or terms of the will are disputed in court. However, challenging a will is difficult and requires solid legal grounds.

Can You Challenge a Will After Death?

Yes. Here’s an overview of the grounds on which a will can be challenged and the process involved:

• It can be argued that the testator was not of sound mind at the time the will was created. This means the person lacked the mental capacity to understand the implications of creating the will, including:

  • Knowing they were making a will.

  • Understanding the nature and extent of their estate.

  • Recognising the beneficiaries and how the estate would be distributed.

• A will can be challenged if it's proven that the testator was under undue influence, pressure, or coercion by someone, which led them to make decisions they otherwise wouldn’t have. For instance, if a family member or caregiver forces or manipulates the testator into leaving assets to them, the will may be considered invalid.

• If the will was created under fraudulent circumstances (e.g., the testator was misled into signing the will) or if the testator’s signature was forged, the will can be challenged.

• For a will to be valid, it must comply with the legal formalities laid down in the relevant law. For example, the will must be signed by the testator and witnessed by two competent witnesses in most jurisdictions. If these requirements are not met, the will can be deemed invalid.

• If there is evidence that the testator revoked the will before their death (for instance, by destroying it or creating a new will), the earlier will can be challenged.

• If there is an ambiguity in the will language, or if the terms are unclear or contradict each other, beneficiaries may challenge the will to clarify its meaning.

• In some jurisdictions, close family members (such as children or spouses) have certain rights to the estate, and a will that disinherits them can be contested. For example, under the Hindu Succession Act in India, legal heirs have a right to challenge a will if they are unfairly excluded.

I hope this solves your query, can a will be challenged after death. Let’s also check:

Who Can Challenge a Will?

• Beneficiaries: Named or excluded beneficiaries who feel that the will does not accurately represent the testator’s wishes.

• Legal Heirs: Close family members (spouse, children, parents) who believe they were unfairly treated or excluded from the will.

• Creditors: In some cases, creditors may challenge a will if they believe the estate should satisfy outstanding debts.

I hope this answers your questions, can a registered will be challenged after death.

Read more:

Before proceeding with what is the time limit to challenge a will in India, you must learn that a will can indeed be challenged after the death of the will-maker. Scroll down to check out some key points to consider.

Can a Registered Will be Challenged after Death?

Yes. But, you need to consider a few points:

1. Legal Requirements: For a will to be valid, it must meet certain legal requirements. These typically include:

   • The will must be in writing.

   • The will-maker (testator) must sign it.

   • Witnesses must also sign the will.

   • The testator must have been of sound mind and not under undue influence or coercion when creating the will.

2. Grounds for Challenging a Will:

   • Lack of Capacity

     : If the testator was not mentally competent when making the will, it can be challenged.

   • Undue Influence

     : If someone exerted undue influence over the testator, leading to changes in the will, it can be contested.

   • Fraud or Forgery

     : If the will was forged or obtained fraudulently, it can be challenged.

   • Improper Execution

     : If the will does not meet legal execution requirements, it may be invalid.

3. Probate Court Process:

   • To challenge a will, interested parties (such as beneficiaries or heirs) need to file a petition in the probate court where the will is being probated.

   • Each state has its own procedures and forms for challenging a will.

   • Seeking legal advice or hiring an attorney is advisable.

The time limit for challenging a will in India is generally up to 12 years following the testator's passing. However, legal heirs may potentially contest a will at any time because the Indian Succession Act of 1925 makes no mention of a deadline. I hope this answer your query can a will be challenged in court.

Hey Pal,

In response to your question, "Can a will be challenged after death in India?" I would like to say Yes! A will is a formal statement of the testator's intentions regarding both his moveable and immovable property. A will can only be carried out after the testator has passed away; if the testator's assets are distributed before to his passing, the document is not a will. The validity of a will after death may also be contested in court, but only within a limited time frame. Therefore, the continued validity of a will is crucial.

Can you challenge a will after death?

The terms of a will must be followed after the testator's demise. Since the main purpose of a will is to carry out the testator's wishes about his properties and other assets. A will's validity may be disputed even after the testator has passed away. To put it simply, a will is valid whether it is registered or unregistered.

There is no time limit on when a will goes into effect. For a period of up to 12 years after the testator's demise, a will may be challenged.

According to the Supreme Court's ruling in Jamnadas v. Naveen Thakral and Others, the civil judge may waive the 12-year deadline if there are valid reasons why some parties may not have known about the will for a lengthy period of time. However, this could compromise natural justice.

A will is still valid and enforceable even after the testator's death. However, there is only a 12-year window in which to contest a will, and if someone want to do so after that time, they must provide justification. The will is deemed to be executed if its provisions have been carried out. Indian law does not have any particular provisions governing the longevity or duration of a will. The term "permanent will" refers to a will that has been in effect for 12 years or more.

We can therefore conclude that there is no temporal limit on the duration of a will's validity because it is valid for the beneficiary's whole lifetime and is always enforceable.

I would like to conclude here about, Can a will be challenged after death in India. I hope this helps:)

Read More: